When to Plant: Your Seasonal Success Guide

When to Plant Your New Garden (And What Nobody Tells You About Each Season)

You've got your garden plan ready, your Pinterest board is overflowing with inspiration, and you're itching to get started. But when should you actually put plants in the ground? The answer isn't as simple as "spring is planting season"—each time of year comes with its own advantages, challenges, and reality checks that garden centers don't always mention.

Here's what planting a new garden actually looks like throughout the year in our corner of Western New York, where Mother Nature has her own opinions about your gardening timeline.

March-April: For the Early Birds

What Everyone Says: "Spring is here! Time to plant!"

The Reality Check: March in Buffalo is like that friend who promises to show up on time but always leaves you waiting. One day it's 60 degrees and you're convinced winter is over, the next day there's snow on your daffodils.

Plant Availability: Garden centers are stocked but mostly with cool-season annuals and early perennials. The good stuff isn't here yet.

Watering Expectations: Moderate. Spring rains usually handle most of it, but you'll need to keep an eye on things during those random warm spells.

Possible Hazards: Late frost is the big killer here. That gorgeous Saturday when you plant your whole garden? There's probably a freeze warning for Tuesday night. Also, your soil might still be too wet to work—walking on saturated soil compacts it into concrete.

Why You Might Choose This Anyway: Cool-season crops (lettuce, peas, spinach) actually prefer this timing. Plus, there's something deeply satisfying about being the first person on your block to get dirty hands. Just stick to hardy plants and keep some old sheets handy for frost protection.

May: Off to the Races

What Everyone Says: "Perfect planting weather!"

The Reality Check: May can be fantastic, or it can dump three inches of rain followed by a week of 40-degree nights. Buffalo's version of "spring" is more like a coin flip.

Plant Availability: This is when garden centers bring out the good stuff. Selection is at its ramping up, and plants are healthy and ready to go.

Watering Expectations: Plan to water regularly. New plants need consistent moisture, and May can be surprisingly dry between rain storms.

Possible Hazards: Late frost can still happen (we've had snow in May, because Buffalo). Also, this is prime planting time for everyone, so expect crowded garden centers and picked-over selections if you wait too long.

Why This Works: If you can dodge the weather curveballs, May gives you the longest growing season. Plants have all summer to establish before winter, and you're working with nature's natural growth cycle.

June-July: For Quick Results

What Everyone Says: "It's too late to plant!"

The Reality Check: This is actually prime time for immediate impact. Yes, plants will need more water, but everything is actively growing and will fill in quickly.

Plant Availability: Garden centers start putting things on sale. Smart shoppers know this is when you can score deals on healthy plants that just need a good home.

Watering Expectations: High maintenance. You'll be watering daily for the first few weeks, possibly twice a day during heat waves. This is not a "plant and forget" situation.

Possible Hazards: Heat stress is real. Plants can go from happy to crispy in one hot afternoon if you're not on top of watering. Also, established weeds are now competing seriously for space.

Why You Might Love This: Instant results. Plants that survive the initial transition will look established by fall. Plus, you know exactly what growing conditions you're dealing with—no guessing about how much sun that "partial shade" spot really gets.

August-September: The Smart Gardener's Season

What Everyone Says: "Too late for planting!"

The Reality Check: This might be the best-kept secret in gardening. Fall planting gives you cool temperatures, fall rains, and a whole season for roots to establish before growth kicks in next spring.

Plant Availability: Many garden centers are clearing inventory, so selection might be limited but prices are often great. This is also prime time for planting trees and shrubs.

Watering Expectations: Moderate and decreasing. You'll need to water initially, but cooler temperatures and fall rains will take over soon.

Possible Hazards: You're racing against winter. Plants need at least 6-8 weeks to establish roots before hard frost. Also, some plants may not bloom much this first year since they're focusing on root development.

Why This Is Brilliant: Plants spend fall and winter developing strong root systems instead of putting energy into flowers and foliage. Come spring, they're ready to take off like they've been there for years.

October-November: My Favorite Time

What Everyone Says: "Gardening season is over!"

The Reality Check: For trees, shrubs, and many perennials, this is actually ideal planting time. The soil is still warm, the air is cool, and plants can establish without summer stress.

Plant Availability: Limited but often deeply discounted. You're shopping the clearance rack, but some of the best deals happen now.

Watering Expectations: Low. Fall rains and cool temperatures mean minimal watering needs.

Possible Hazards: Timing is everything. Plant too late and roots won't establish before the ground freezes. Also, don't expect much action above ground until spring.

Why Pros Do This: Root development happens all winter in unfrozen soil. Spring growth is explosive because the plant already has an established root system. Plus, you avoid the spring rush and get better prices.

December-February: Planning Time

What Everyone Says: Nothing. Nobody talks about winter planting because it's ridiculous.

The Reality Check: In Buffalo, these months are basically a gardening timeout. The ground is frozen solid, garden centers are selling Christmas decorations, and any plant discussion involves houseplants or seed catalogs.

Plant Availability: Basically zero, unless you count the sad poinsettias at the grocery store.

Watering Expectations: Your plants are either dead or dormant. Either way, they're not thirsty.

Possible Hazards: Cabin fever leading to impulse seed purchases and overly ambitious garden plans.

Why You Shouldn't Even Try: Because it's Buffalo in winter. The only thing you should be planting is yourself on the couch with seed catalogs, planning for next year.

The Bottom Line

The "right" time to plant depends on what you're planting and how much maintenance you're willing to commit to. Spring planting gives you the longest growing season but requires patience with weather. Summer planting gives instant results but demands constant attention. Fall planting is low-maintenance but requires faith that your investment will pay off next year.

The truth is, plants are tougher than we give them credit for. With proper care, you can successfully plant almost any time the ground isn't frozen. The key is matching your planting time to your lifestyle, patience level, and watering commitment.

Just remember: in Buffalo, always keep an eye on the weather forecast, no matter what month you choose.

Shop Our Landscape Designs